The Debate About Cloning
There are two types of cloning. One involves harvesting stem cells from embryos ("therapeutic cloning"). These are the biological equivalent of a template. They can develop into any kind of mature functional cell and thus help cure many degenerative and auto-immune diseases.
The other kind of cloning is much derided in popular culture - and elsewhere - as the harbinger of a Brave, New World. A nucleus from any cell of a donor is embedded in an egg whose own nucleus has been removed. The egg is then implanted in a woman's womb and a cloned baby is born nine months later. Biologically, the cloned infant is a replica of the donor.
Cloning is often confused with other advances in bio-medicine and bio-engineering - such as genetic selection. It cannot - in itself - be used to produce "perfect humans" or select sex or other traits. Hence, some of the arguments against cloning are either specious or fuelled by ignorance.
It is true, though, that cloning, used in conjunction with other bio-technologies, raises serious bio-ethical questions. Scare scenarios of humans cultivated in sinister labs as sources of spare body parts, "designer babies", "master races", or "genetic sex slaves" - formerly the preserve of B sci-fi movies - have invaded mainstream discourse.
Still, cloning touches upon Mankind's most basic fears and hopes. It invokes the most intractable ethical and moral dilemmas. As an inevitable result, the debate is often more passionate than informed.
I. Right to Life Arguments
According to cloning's detractors, the nucleus removed from the egg could otherwise have developed into a human being. Thus, removing the nucleus amounts to murder.
It is a fundamental principle of most moral theories that all human beings have a right to life. The existence of a right implies obligations or duties of third parties towards the right-holder. One has a right AGAINST other people. The fact that one possesses a certain right - prescribes to others certain obligatory behaviours and proscribes certain acts or omissions. This Janus-like nature of rights and duties as two sides of the same ethical coin - creates great confusion. People often and easily confuse rights and their attendant duties or obligations with the morally decent, or even with the morally permissible. What one MUST do as a result of another's right - should never be confused with one SHOULD or OUGHT to do morally (in the absence of a right).
The right to life has eight distinct strains:
IA. The right to be brought to life
IB. The right to be born
IC. The right to have one's life maintained
ID. The right not to be killed
IE. The right to have one's life saved
IF. The right to save one's life (erroneously limited to the right to self-defence)
IG. The right to terminate one's life
IH. The right to have one's life terminated
IA. The Right to be Brought to Life
Only living people have rights. There is a debate whether an egg is a living person - but there can be no doubt that it exists. Its rights - whatever they are - derive from the fact that it exists and that it has the potential to develop life. The right to be brought to life (the right to become or to be) pertains to a yet non-alive entity and, therefore, is null and void. Had this right existed, it would have implied an obligation or duty to give life to the unborn and the not yet conceived. No such duty or obligation exist.
IB. The Right to be Born
The right to be born crystallizes at the moment of voluntary and intentional fertilization. If a scientist knowingly and intentionally causes in vitro fertilization for the explicit and express purpose of creating an embryo - then the resulting fertilized egg has a right to mature and be born. Furthermore, the born child has all the rights a child has against his parents: food, shelter, emotional nourishment, education, and so on.
It is debatable whether such rights of the fetus and, later, of the child, exist if there was no positive act of fertilization - but, on the contrary, an act which prevents possible fertilization, such as the removal of the nucleus (see IC below).
IC. The Right to Have One's Life Maintained
Does one have the right to maintain one's life and prolong them at other people's expense? Does one have the right to use other people's bodies, their property, their time, their resources and to deprive them of pleasure, comfort, material possessions, income, or any other thing?
The answer is yes and no.
No one has a right to sustain his or her life, maintain, or prolong them at another INDIVIDUAL's expense (no matter how minimal and insignificant the sacrifice required is). Still, if a contract has been signed - implicitly or explicitly - between the parties, then such a right may crystallize in the contract and create corresponding duties and obligations, moral, as well as legal.
No fetus has a right to sustain its life, maintain, or prolong them at his mother's expense (no matter how minimal and insignificant the sacrifice required of her is). Still, if she signed a contract with the fetus - by knowingly and willingly and intentionally conceiving it - such a right has crystallized and has created corresponding duties and obligations of the mother towards her fetus.
On the other hand, everyone has a right to sustain his or her life, maintain, or prolong them at SOCIETY's expense (no matter how major and significant the resources required are). Still, if a contract has been signed - implicitly or explicitly - between the parties, then the abrogation of such a right may crystallize in the contract and create corresponding duties and obligations, moral, as well as legal.
Everyone has a right to sustain his or her life, maintain, or prolong them at society's expense. Public hospitals, state pension schemes, and police forces may be required to fulfill society's obligations - but fulfill them it must, no matter how major and significant the resources are. Still, if a person volunteered to join the army and a contract has been signed between the parties, then this right has been thus abrogated and the individual assumed certain duties and obligations, including the duty or obligation to give up his or her life to society.
ID. The Right not to be Killed
Every person has the right not to be killed unjustly. What constitutes "just killing" is a matter for an ethical calculus in the framework of a social contract.
But does A's right not to be killed include the right against third parties that they refrain from enforcing the rights of other people against A? Does A's right not to be killed preclude the righting of wrongs committed by A against others - even if the righting of such wrongs means the killing of A?
Not so. There is a moral obligation to right wrongs (to restore the rights of other people). If A maintains or prolongs his life ONLY by violating the rights of others and these other people object to it - then A must be killed if that is the only way to right the wrong and re-assert their rights.
This is doubly true if A's existence is, at best, debatable. An egg does not a human being make. Removal of the nucleus is an important step in life-saving research. An unfertilized egg has no rights at all.
IE. The Right to Have One's Life Saved
There is no such right as there is no corresponding moral obligation or duty to save a life. This "right" is a demonstration of the aforementioned muddle between the morally commendable, desirable and decent ("ought", "should") and the morally obligatory, the result of other people's rights ("must").
In some countries, the obligation to save life is legally codified. But while the law of the land may create a LEGAL right and corresponding LEGAL obligations - it does not always or necessarily create a moral or an ethical right and corresponding moral duties and obligations.
IF. The Right to Save One's Own Life
The right to self-defence is a subset of the more general and all-pervasive right to save one's own life. One has the right to take certain actions or avoid taking certain actions in order to save his or her own life.
It is generally accepted that one has the right to kill a pursuer who knowingly and intentionally intends to take one's life. It is debatable, though, whether one has the right to kill an innocent person who unknowingly and unintentionally threatens to take one's life.
IG. The Right to Terminate One's Life
See "The Murder of Oneself".
IH. The Right to Have One's Life Terminated
The right to euthanasia, to have one's life terminated at will, is restricted by numerous social, ethical, and legal rules, principles, and considerations. In a nutshell - in many countries in the West one is thought to has a right to have one's life terminated with the help of third parties if one is going to die shortly anyway and if one is going to be tormented and humiliated by great and debilitating agony for the rest of one's remaining life if not helped to die. Of course, for one's wish to be helped to die to be accommodated, one has to be in sound mind and to will one's death knowingly, intentionally, and forcefully.
II. Issues in the Calculus of Rights
IIA. The Hierarchy of Rights
All human cultures have hierarchies of rights. These hierarchies reflect cultural mores and lores and there cannot, therefore, be a universal, or eternal hierarchy.
In Western moral systems, the Right to Life supersedes all other rights (including the right to one's body, to comfort, to the avoidance of pain, to property, etc.).
Yet, this hierarchical arrangement does not help us to resolve cases in which there is a clash of EQUAL rights (for instance, the conflicting rights to life of two people). One way to decide among equally potent claims is randomly (by flipping a coin, or casting dice). Alternatively, we could add and subtract rights in a somewhat macabre arithmetic. If a mother's life is endangered by the continued existence of a fetus and assuming both of them have a right to life we can decide to kill the fetus by adding to the mother's right to life her right to her own body and thus outweighing the fetus' right to life.
IIB. The Difference between Killing and Letting Die
There is an assumed difference between killing (taking life) and letting die (not saving a life). This is supported by IE above. While there is a right not to be killed - there is no right to have one's own life saved. Thus, while there is an obligation not to kill - there is no obligation to save a life.
IIC. Killing the Innocent
Often the continued existence of an innocent person (IP) threatens to take the life of a victim (V). By "innocent" we mean "not guilty" - not responsible for killing V, not intending to kill V, and not knowing that V will be killed due to IP's actions or continued existence.
It is simple to decide to kill IP to save V if IP is going to die anyway shortly, and the remaining life of V, if saved, will be much longer than the remaining life of IP, if not killed. All other variants require a calculus of hierarchically weighted rights. (See "Abortion and the Sanctity of Human Life" by Baruch A. Brody).
One form of calculus is the utilitarian theory. It calls for the maximization of utility (life, happiness, pleasure). In other words, the life, happiness, or pleasure of the many outweigh the life, happiness, or pleasure of the few. It is morally permissible to kill IP if the lives of two or more people will be saved as a result and there is no other way to save their lives. Despite strong philosophical objections to some of the premises of utilitarian theory - I agree with its practical prescriptions.
In this context - the dilemma of killing the innocent - one can also call upon the right to self defence. Does V have a right to kill IP regardless of any moral calculus of rights? Probably not. One is rarely justified in taking another's life to save one's own. But such behaviour cannot be condemned. Here we have the flip side of the confusion - understandable and perhaps inevitable behaviour (self defence) is mistaken for a MORAL RIGHT. That most V's would kill IP and that we would all sympathize with V and understand its behaviour does not mean that V had a RIGHT to kill IP. V may have had a right to kill IP - but this right is not automatic, nor is it all-encompassing.
But is the Egg - Alive?
This question is NOT equivalent to the ancient quandary of "when does life begin". Life crystallizes, at the earliest, when an egg and a sperm unite (i.e., at the moment of fertilization). Life is not a potential - it is a process triggered by an event. An unfertilized egg is neither a process - nor an event. It does not even possess the potential to become alive unless and until it merges with a sperm. Should such merger not occur - it will never develop life.
The potential to become X is not the ontological equivalent of actually being X, nor does it spawn moral and ethical rights and obligations pertaining to X. The transition from potential to being is not trivial, nor is it automatic, or inevitable, or independent of context. Atoms of various elements have the potential to become an egg (or, for that matter, a human being) - yet no one would claim that they ARE an egg (or a human being), or that they should be treated as one (i.e., with the same rights and obligations).
Moreover, it is the donor nucleus embedded in the egg that endows it with life - the life of the cloned baby. Yet, the nucleus is usually extracted from a muscle or the skin. Should we treat a muscle or a skin cell with the same reverence the critics of cloning wish to accord an unfertilized egg?
Is This the Main Concern?
The main concern is that cloning - even the therapeutic kind - will produce piles of embryos. Many of them - close to 95% with current biotechnology - will die. Others can be surreptitiously and illegally implanted in the wombs of "surrogate mothers".
It is patently immoral, goes the precautionary argument, to kill so many embryos. Cloning is such a novel technique that its success rate is still unacceptably low. There are alternative ways to harvest stem cells - less costly in terms of human life. If we accept that life begins at the moment of fertilization, this argument is valid. But it also implies that - once cloning becomes safer and scientists more adept - cloning itself should be permitted.
This is anathema to those who fear a slippery slope. They abhor the very notion of "unnatural" conception. To them, cloning is a narcissistic act and an ignorant and dangerous interference in nature's sagacious ways. They would ban procreative cloning, regardless of how safe it is. Therapeutic cloning - with its mounds of discarded fetuses - will allow rogue scientists to cross the boundary between permissible (curative cloning) and illegal (baby cloning).
Why Should Baby Cloning be Illegal?
Cloning's opponents object to procreative cloning because it can be abused to design babies, skew natural selection, unbalance nature, produce masters and slaves and so on. The "argument from abuse" has been raised with every scientific advance - from in vitro fertilization to space travel.
Every technology can be potentially abused. Television can be either a wonderful educational tool - or an addictive and mind numbing pastime. Nuclear fission is a process that yields both nuclear weapons and atomic energy. To claim, as many do, that cloning touches upon the "heart" of our existence, the "kernel" of our being, the very "essence" of our nature - and thus threatens life itself - would be incorrect.
There is no "privileged" form of technological abuse and no hierarchy of potentially abusive technologies. Nuclear fission tackles natural processes as fundamental as life. Nuclear weapons threaten life no less than cloning. The potential for abuse is not a sufficient reason to arrest scientific research and progress - though it is a necessary condition.
Some fear that cloning will further the government's enmeshment in the healthcare system and in scientific research. Power corrupts and it is not inconceivable that governments will ultimately abuse and misuse cloning and other biotechnologies. Nazi Germany had a state-sponsored and state-mandated eugenics program in the 1930's.
Yet, this is another variant of the argument from abuse. That a technology can be abused by governments does not imply that it should be avoided or remain undeveloped. This is because all technologies - without a single exception - can and are abused routinely - by governments and others. This is human nature.
Fukuyama raised the possibility of a multi-tiered humanity in which "natural" and "genetically modified" people enjoy different rights and privileges. But why is this inevitable? Surely this can easily by tackled by proper, prophylactic, legislation?
All humans, regardless of their pre-natal history, should be treated equally. Are children currently conceived in vitro treated any differently to children conceived in utero? They are not. There is no reason that cloned or genetically-modified children should belong to distinct legal classes.
It is very anthropocentric to argue that the proliferation of genetically enhanced or genetically selected children will somehow unbalance nature and destabilize the precarious equilibrium it maintains. After all, humans have been modifying, enhancing, and eliminating hundreds of thousands of species for well over 10,000 years now. Genetic modification and bio-engineering are as natural as agriculture. Human beings are a part of nature and its manifestation. By definition, everything they do is natural.
Why would the genetic alteration or enhancement of one more species - homo sapiens - be of any consequence? In what way are humans "more important" to nature, or "more crucial" to its proper functioning? In our short history on this planet, we have genetically modified and enhanced wheat and rice, dogs and cows, tulips and orchids, oranges and potatoes. Why would interfering with the genetic legacy of the human species be any different?
Effects on Society
Cloning - like the Internet, the television, the car, electricity, the telegraph, and the wheel before it - is bound to have great social consequences. It may foster "embryo industries". It may lead to the exploitation of women - either willingly ("egg prostitution") or unwillingly ("womb slavery"). Charles Krauthammer, a columnist and psychiatrist, quoted in "The Economist", says:
"(Cloning) means the routinisation, the commercialisation, the commodification of the human embryo."
Exploiting anyone unwillingly is a crime, whether it involves cloning or white slavery. But why would egg donations and surrogate motherhood be considered problems? If we accept that life begins at the moment of fertilization and that a woman owns her body and everything within it - why should she not be allowed to sell her eggs or to host another's baby and how would these voluntary acts be morally repugnant? In any case, human eggs are already being bought and sold and the supply far exceeds the demand.
Moreover, full-fledged humans are routinely "routinised, commercialized, and commodified" by governments, corporations, religions, and other social institutions. Consider war, for instance - or commercial advertising. How is the "routinisation, commercialization, and commodification" of embryos more reprehensible that the "routinisation, commercialization, and commodification" of fully formed human beings?
Curing and Saving Life
Cell therapy based on stem cells often leads to tissue rejection and necessitates costly and potentially dangerous immunosuppressive therapy. But when the stem cells are harvested from the patient himself and cloned, these problems are averted. Therapeutic cloning has vast untapped - though at this stage still remote - potential to improve the lives of hundreds of millions.
As far as "designer babies" go, pre-natal cloning and genetic engineering can be used to prevent disease or cure it, to suppress unwanted traits, and to enhance desired ones. It is the moral right of a parent to make sure that his progeny suffers less, enjoys life more, and attains the maximal level of welfare throughout his or her life.
That such technologies can be abused by over-zealous, or mentally unhealthy parents in collaboration with avaricious or unscrupulous doctors - should not prevent the vast majority of stable, caring, and sane parents from gaining access to them.
About The Author
Sam Vaknin is the author of Malignant Self Love - Narcissism Revisited and After the Rain - How the West Lost the East. He is a columnist for Central Europe Review, PopMatters, and eBookWeb , a United Press International (UPI) Senior Business Correspondent, and the editor of mental health and Central East Europe categories in The Open Directory Bellaonline, and Suite101 .
Until recently, he served as the Economic Advisor to the Government of Macedonia.
This Week in Science Science Magazine
Stereocilia are hair-like structures in the inner ear that transform sound vibration into a neural signal. These structures stop growing in humans early in fetal ...
Would You Travel Across The World For 62 Seconds Of Science? Countdown Begins To Super-Short Eclipse - Forbes
Would You Travel Across The World For 62 Seconds Of Science? Countdown Begins To Super-Short Eclipse Forbes
A once-a-decade “hybrid” solar eclipse coming up in Western Australia's North-West Cape is super-short, but it kicks-off five Antipodean total solar eclipses in ...
New paper proposes a science-based ‘Global Deal for Nature’ Mongabay.com
A paper published in Science today outlines a new “Global Deal for Nature,” officially launching an effort to establish science-based conservation targets ...
How to Cook With Weed—and a Dash of Tasty, Tasty Science WIRED
Mac and cheese. Peanut butter and jelly. Asparagus and … cannabis oil with a citrusy terpene profile? Welcome to the heady world of cannabis cuisine.
To amp up solar cells, scientists ditch silicon Science Magazine
Silicon dominates the world of solar power. Even the newest solar cell designs, tandem devices that have a silicon solar cell below a cell made of a crystalline ...
Protected area targets post-2020 Science Magazine
In 2010, Parties to the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) adopted the Strategic Plan for Biodiversity 2011–2020, and its 20 Aichi Biodiversity Targets, ...
Hayabusa2 arrives at the carbonaceous asteroid 162173 Ryugu—A spinning top–shaped rubble pile - Science Magazine
Hayabusa2 arrives at the carbonaceous asteroid 162173 Ryugu—A spinning top–shaped rubble pile Science Magazine
Asteroids fall to Earth in the form of meteorites, but these provide little information about their origins. The Japanese mission Hayabusa2 is designed to collect ...
Brazil's Jair Bolsanaro slashes funding to scientists. The planet may suffer. National Geographic
When Jair Bolsonaro began his presidency of Brazil in January he quickly began making good on his campaign promises to rollback protections of the Amazon ...
7 Things That Make You More Attractive, According to Science Newsmax
Attraction is about more than just looks, or at least that is what growing research is showing. We all have a list of traits to explain why we are attracted to certain ...
Scientists take DNA test, learn they’re cousins who’ve collaborated in science journal - The Next Web
Scientists take DNA test, learn they’re cousins who’ve collaborated in science journal The Next Web
When people submit their DNA to companies such as 23andMe for testing, they're usually not too surprised to find out they have relatives they haven't met.
Exclusive: Major U.S. cancer center ousts 'Asian' researchers after NIH flags their foreign ties - Science Magazine
Exclusive: Major U.S. cancer center ousts 'Asian' researchers after NIH flags their foreign ties Science Magazine
HOUSTON, TEXAS—The MD Anderson Cancer Center here has ousted three senior researchers after the U.S. National Institutes of Health (NIH) in Bethesda, ...
Nature meets science in museum exhibit | UDaily UDaily
*Content* developed by UD professor displayed at Delaware Museum of Natural History.
Is There A Science To Attraction? I Smelled A Stranger To Find Out Refinery29
I attended Guerilla Science's Attraction Lab — and sniffed a stranger, blindfolded.
Sonar Anomaly Leads to Discovery of 500-Year-Old Shipwreck in North Sea Live Science
Salvagers looking for steel shipping containers at the bottom of the North Sea have discovered a 500-year-old Dutch shipwreck holding a cargo of tons of copper ...
Engineering researcher uses network science to understand how materials work Science Daily
Using network science -- part of a larger mathematical field called graph theory -- a professor mapped long range atomic forces onto an incredibly complex ...
Cytosine base editor generates substantial off-target single-nucleotide variants in mouse embryos - Science Magazine
Cytosine base editor generates substantial off-target single-nucleotide variants in mouse embryos Science Magazine
Unintended genomic modifications limit the potential therapeutic use of gene-editing tools. Available methods to find off-targets generally do not work in vivo or ...
Baby tyrannosaur's eBay auction sparks outrage Science Magazine
It's astonishing what you can buy on eBay. An ongoing auction on the site offers buyers the chance to own what is claimed to be “maybe the only” juvenile ...
How US–China political tensions are affecting science Nature.com
Conference travel, research visas, science funding and security clearance are all touched by the geopolitics.
Scientists Uncover California's Hidden Earthquakes Scientific American
Scientific American is the essential guide to the most awe-inspiring advances in science and technology, explaining how they change our understanding of the ...
A scientist used chalk in a box to show that bats use sunsets to migrate Science News
When it comes to migration science, birds rule. Although many mammals — antelopes, whales, bats — migrate, too, scientists know far less about how those ...
Can science writing be automated? A neural network can read scientific papers and render a plain-English summary - Science Daily
Can science writing be automated? A neural network can read scientific papers and render a plain-English summary Science Daily
A team of researchers has developed a neural network, a form of artificial intelligence, that can read scientific papers and render a plain-English summary in a ...
The herbal supplement kratom comes with risks Science News
The supplement kratom can cause heart racing and agitation.
We regret to inform you Science Magazine
I woke up and groggily checked my phone—my morning routine. When I saw the email, I instantly became alert. It was from the National Science Foundation ...
BRHS Students Earn Top Honors At Alaska State Science And Engineering Fair KYUK
Two Bethel Regional High School students took top honors in the state science and engineering fair. Calvin Sampson won first place in the “Animal Science”
An engineer at Uber's self-driving-car unit warns that it's more like 'a science experiment' than a real car capable of driving itself - Business Insider
An engineer at Uber's self-driving-car unit warns that it's more like 'a science experiment' than a real car capable of driving itself Business Insider
People inside Uber said that its self-driving car still doesn't drive itself all that well.
The heart and science of kindness - Harvard Health Blog Harvard Health
Acts of kindness -- to loved ones, to strangers, to ourselves -- make the world a warmer place. And seeking ways to be kind can make you happier, too.
Women scientists get the Wikipedia pages they deserve thanks to UNC's Science Library - The Daily Tar Heel
Women scientists get the Wikipedia pages they deserve thanks to UNC's Science Library The Daily Tar Heel
UNC's Kenan Science Library hosted its fourth annual Women in Science Wikipedia Edit-a-thon this week. Participants gathered Wednesday from 5 to 8 p.m. to ...
Animal Migrations in the Spring | Science Smithsonian.com
As temperatures rise and foliage blooms in the north, creatures from insects to whales set out for long treks across the planet.
Shadowy first image of black hole revealed Science Magazine
Two decades ago, Eric Agol, an astronomer at the University of Washington in Seattle, first modeled how a black hole's intense gravity would bend light around it ...
Millipede Genitals Glow Different Colors (But Scientists Can't Explain Why) Live Science
Scientists recently discovered that numerous millipede species fluoresce, and the glow of their genitals varies between species.
#MeToo controversy erupts at archaeology meeting Science Magazine
When Norma Johnson, a graduate student in archaeology at the University of Alaska in Anchorage (UAA), walked across the convention center floor to get ...
Can science survive without statistical significance? Science News
In science, the success of an experiment is often determined by a measure called “statistical significance.” A result is considered to be “significant” if the ...
Cheap, portable scanners could transform brain imaging. But how will scientists deliver the data? - Science Magazine
Cheap, portable scanners could transform brain imaging. But how will scientists deliver the data? Science Magazine
Q&A with neuroethicist Francis Shen and MRI developer Michael Garwood.
The history and future of neurological care Science Magazine
I was a teenager when I first read Oliver Sacks. I was enchanted, and I read him whenever possible in college and afterward. Sacks could take a simple ...
‘Partly Alive’: Scientists Revive Cells in Brains From Dead Pigs The New York Times
In a study that upends assumptions about brain death, researchers brought some cells back to life — or something like it.
CUPD investigating robbery Friday night outside Hale Science cuindependent
The campus police department is investigating a strong-arm robbery that took place Friday night outside of the Hale Science building. According to a statement ...
National University of Columbia Joins Blockchain Global Consortium for Science Cointelegraph
News. The National University of Columbia is joining the global blockchain consortium for science dubbed Bloxberg, Mauricio Tovar Gutiérrez, co-director of the ...
How conducting polymer electrodes operate Science Magazine
Organic electrochemical devices, which use conjugated polymers in contact with an electrolyte, have applications in bioelectronics, energy storage, ...
Second NASA Astronaut to Spend Nearly a Year in Space — For Science Space.com
NASA astronaut Christina Koch will spend nearly a year in space, the agency announced Wednesday (April 17), and that will offer scientists much-needed data ...
'Invisible Women' spotlights a gaping and dangerous gender data gap Science News
'Invisible Women' explains how neglecting to collect or use data on women harms their health and safety.
Urine salts elucidate Early Neolithic animal management at Aşıklı Höyük, Turkey Science Advances
The process of sheep and goat (caprine) domestication began by 9000 to 8000 BCE in Southwest Asia. The early Neolithic site at Aşıklı Höyük in central Turkey ...
Astronomers have spotted the universe's first molecule Science Magazine
The universe's very first molecule, thought to be created after the big bang, has been detected in space for the first time. Helium hydride (HeH), a combination of ...
NASA Psyche Spacecraft Bound for Metal Asteroid | Science Smithsonian
The Psyche spacecraft, headed to an asteroid with the same name, will explore a metal world thought to be the leftover core of a destroyed planet.
New climate models predict a warming surge Science Magazine
For nearly 40 years, the massive computer models used to simulate global climate have delivered a fairly consistent picture of how fast human carbon emissions ...
Glowing genitalia reveal the identity of mysterious millipedes Science Magazine
Some insects are easy to tell apart. Others, not so much. Some flat-backed millipedes in the genus Pseudopolydesmus look almost identical regardless of their ...
A genetic scorecard could predict your risk of being obese Science News
A genetic score predicts who is at risk of severe obesity, but experts say lifestyle matters more than genes.
Housework could keep brain young, research suggests The Guardian
Even light activity such as household chores might help to keep the brain young, researchers say, adding to a growing body of evidence that, when it comes to ...
NG-11 Cygnus, SS Roger Chaffee, brings the science to ISS NASASpaceflight.com
Roughly 37 hours after launching from the Mid-Atlantic Regional Spaceport (MARS) in Virginia, Northrop Grumman's NG-11 Cygnus spacecraft has arrived at ...
Deconstructing water's diffuse OH stretching vibrational spectrum with cold clusters - Science Magazine
Deconstructing water's diffuse OH stretching vibrational spectrum with cold clusters Science Magazine
In principle, the surface structure of water (H2O) should be discernable from the O–H vibrations. In practice, however, so many configurations rapidly interconvert ...
Unbiased detection of CRISPR off-targets in vivo using DISCOVER-Seq Science Magazine
Unintended genomic modifications limit the potential therapeutic use of gene-editing tools. Available methods to find off-targets generally do not work in vivo or ...
Warm, dry winds may be straining Antarctica's Larsen C ice shelf Science News
Wind-induced melting that occurred during the Antarctic autumn may be accelerating the Larsen C ice shelf's collapse, which could raise sea levels.
New Twitter account outs shoddy reporting in science stories Quartz
In this era of fake news, it's not unusual for social media users—including the US president—to accuse journalists of doing bad work. Sadly, when it comes to ...
Here's what scientists think a black hole looks like Science Magazine
Astronomers may have imaged a black hole for the first time, capping decades of calculations of how they ought to appear.
Science during crisis Science Magazine
In April 1902, on the Caribbean island of Martinique, La Commission sur le Vulcan convened to make a fateful decision. Mt. Pelée was sending smoke aloft and ...
Probing Rényi entanglement entropy via randomized measurements Science Magazine
Quantum systems are predicted to be better at information processing than their classical counterparts, and quantum entanglement is key to this superior ...
Hurricane Michael was even more powerful than scientists initially thought BGR
The science of tracking hurricanes has seen huge advancements in recent years, allowing forecasters to better predict paths and overall impact of the large ...
Arc-continent collisions in the tropics set Earth's climate state Science Magazine
On million-year time scales, Earth's climate state is determined by sources and sinks of carbon to the ocean-atmosphere system. But which specific mechanisms ...
Three tips for giving a great research talk Science Magazine
In this Letter to Young Scientists, our columnists share advice for communicating your research clearly and compellingly.
Want to Live Longer? Science Says to Do These 5 Things TIME
Many people want to live longer. These five habits can boost health, improve longevity and prevent chronic disease, according to research.
Scientists Used Human Tissue to 3-D Print a Tiny Heart Smithsonian.com
Researchers have successfully 3-D printed a miniature heart complete with cells, blood vessels, ventricles and chambers. The engineered organ—crafted using ...
Archaeological society tries to stem continuing controversy over #MeToo scandal Science Magazine
The Society for American Archaeology (SAA) continues to battle fallout for the way it handled a #MeToo scandal at its annual meeting last week.
A planetesimal orbiting within the debris disc around a white dwarf star Science Magazine
Numerous exoplanets have been detected around Sun-like stars. These stars end their lives as white dwarfs, which should inherit any surviving planetary ...
The NASA Twins Study: A multidimensional analysis of a year-long human spaceflight - Science Magazine
The NASA Twins Study: A multidimensional analysis of a year-long human spaceflight Science Magazine
Space is the final frontier for understanding how extreme environments affect human physiology. Following twin astronauts, one of which spent a year-long ...
Concerns of young protesters are justified Science Magazine
The world's youth have begun to persistently demonstrate for the protection of the climate and other foundations of human well-being. (1, 2). As scientists and ...
Is Dentistry a Science? The Atlantic
It's much less scientific—and more prone to gratuitous procedures—than you may think.
Spontaneous behaviors drive multidimensional, brainwide activity Science Magazine
How is it that groups of neurons dispersed through the brain interact to generate complex behaviors? Three papers in this issue present brain-scale studies of ...
Ebola outbreak continues despite powerful vaccine Science Magazine
Even a terrifically effective Ebola vaccine cannot stop an outbreak if nearly 20% of the people who most need it either cannot be reached or refuse to take the ...
Americans Are Smart About Science FiveThirtyEight
Hey, didja hear about those scientifically illiterate Americans? People so dumb, they think the sun revolves around the Earth? People who can't pass a quiz of ...
Airborne microplastics found atop France's remote Pyrenees mountains Science Magazine
Microscopic fragments of plastic have invaded the farthest reaches of the sea, from the depths of the Mariana Trench to the freezing waters off Antarctica. Now ...
Powerful CRISPR cousin accidentally mutates RNA while editing DNA target Science Magazine
When researchers first reported 3 years ago that they had created base editors, a version of the powerful genome-editing tool CRISPR, excitement swirled ...
Scientists create a "lifelike" material that has metabolism and can self-reproduce Big Think
Cornell University engineers have created an artificial material that has three key traits of life — metabolism, self-assembly and organization. The engineers ...
Africa's largest mammalian carnivore had canines 'the size of bananas' Science Magazine
When paleontologists dug up the bones of Africa's largest carnivore in the early 1980s, they had no idea what they had found. So many other fossils littered the ...
Scientists decry USDA's decision to end cat parasite research Science Magazine
For the past 37 years, a small research lab in Beltsville, Maryland, has been the world's leading hub for scientists working on Toxoplasma gondii, a parasite that ...
Top stories: Vaccine durability, the universe's first molecule, and CRISPR's powerful cousin - Science Magazine
Top stories: Vaccine durability, the universe's first molecule, and CRISPR's powerful cousin Science Magazine
Vaccines for the flu, mumps, pertussis, meningococcal disease, and yellow fever all lose their effectiveness faster than official immunization recommendations ...
Evidence for hormonal control of heart regenerative capacity during endothermy acquisition - Science Magazine
Evidence for hormonal control of heart regenerative capacity during endothermy acquisition Science Magazine
Among vertebrates, zebrafish and salamanders can regenerate their hearts, whereas adult mice and humans cannot. Hirose et al. analyzed diploid ...
Former CSIRO researcher accuses science agency of pro-alcohol research The Guardian
Exclusive: Dr Saul Newman says public money is used to subsidise an industry with 'devastating effects on global health'
Rare footage of river dolphins helps scientists crack mystery of marine mammal communication - Fox News
Rare footage of river dolphins helps scientists crack mystery of marine mammal communication Fox News
Brazil's Araguaian river dolphins may not be as big of a loner as researchers previously thought.
Cascading impacts of large-carnivore extirpation in an African ecosystem Science Magazine
War ravages human lives and landscapes, but nonhuman victims are no less affected. The Mozambican Civil War resulted in the rapid decline of predators in ...
The moon is losing 200 tons of water a year to meteorite strikes Science Magazine
When meteorites slam into the moon, they undoubtedly kick up a little dust. Now, a new study suggests they also shake loose quite a bit of water—something on ...
A 2014 meteor may have come from another solar system Science News
Earth may already have been visited by an object from outside our solar system — a meteor that burned up in the planet's atmosphere in 2014, astronomers ...
Update: Legislator asks Pentagon to restore contract for storied Jason science advisory group - Science Magazine
Update: Legislator asks Pentagon to restore contract for storied Jason science advisory group Science Magazine
*Update, 11 April, 3:30 p.m.: The legislator who revealed the Pentagon's decision to terminate the Jason contract during a congressional hearing earlier this ...
This fungus has wiped out more species than any other disease Science Magazine
The infectious disease that has devastated the most biodiversity is a fungal killer of amphibians, researchers report today in Science . Around the world, 90 ...
Charities plug gap in school science | News The Times
Children are doing serious scientific study in some cash-strapped schools with the help of charities that are replacing worn out laboratory equipment and ...
Amphibian fungal panzootic causes catastrophic and ongoing loss of biodiversity Science Magazine
Rapid spread of disease is a hazard in our interconnected world. The chytrid fungus Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis was identified in amphibian populations ...
We cheer on women in the sciences, but recruiting and retaining them is still a different story - CNN
We cheer on women in the sciences, but recruiting and retaining them is still a different story CNN
A recent study shows that almost a quarter of women in STEM change career fields after having children. Why? Learn about current issues surrounding women ...
‘I Want What My Male Colleague Has, and That Will Cost a Few Million Dollars’ The New York Times
Women at the Salk Institute say they faced a culture of marginalization and hostility. The numbers from other elite scientific institutions suggest they're not alone.
Believe in Atlantis? These archaeologists want to win you back to science Science Magazine
In February, the popular podcast The Joe Rogan Experience referred to an idea made famous by some books and TV shows: that an image of the Mayan King ...
South Carolina's science fair champ provides clean drinking water in Bangladesh - Charleston Post Courier
South Carolina's science fair champ provides clean drinking water in Bangladesh Charleston Post Courier
Ishraq Haque, a sophomore at Academic High School in North Charleston, didn't just win two science fair competitions, his entry (an arsenic filtration system for ...
Archaeologists unearth largest Mayan figurine factory to date Science Magazine
ALBUQUERQUE, NEW MEXICO—Archaeologists working in Guatemala have discovered the largest known figurine workshop in the Mayan world, they ...
Human impact erodes chimpanzee behavioral diversity Science Magazine
We often frame negative human impacts on animal species in terms of numbers of individuals reduced or numbers of regions from which species are absent.
David Thouless obituary The Guardian
David Thouless, who has died aged 84, won half of the 2016 Nobel prize in physics, the other half being shared by Duncan Haldane and me. David and I solved ...
Israeli scientists print world's first 3-D heart - Science & Health Haaretz
The future is here, and it's alive and beating. Scientists at Tel Aviv University have printed the world's first 3-D heart complete with blood vessels using ...
Hazards of human spaceflight Science Magazine
In Einstein's famous twin paradox, the effect of special relativity causes aging to slow in one twin during travel in a high-speed rocket through space while the ...
Autologous grafting of cryopreserved prepubertal rhesus testis produces sperm and offspring - Science Magazine
Autologous grafting of cryopreserved prepubertal rhesus testis produces sperm and offspring Science Magazine
Before chemotherapy or radiation treatment, sperm from adult men can be cryopreserved for future use. However, this is not possible for prepubertal boys.
Tweeting while flying kills migratory birds Science Magazine
Texting while driving can be deadly. So can tweeting while flying, a new study finds—among some species of migratory birds. Researchers have found that birds ...
The black hole image and Katie Bouman: the sexist backlash against her, explained Vox.com
Just after the Event Horizon Telescope project announced last week that its astronomers had managed to capture the first-ever image of a black hole, MIT ...
Liquid blood taken from 42,000-year-old frozen horse that scientists hope to clone Fox News
Scientists were able to extract liquid blood from the heart of a 42000-year-old foal that had been frozen and preserved in permafrost in Siberia.
Sustained rescue of prefrontal circuit dysfunction by antidepressant-induced spine formation - Science Magazine
Sustained rescue of prefrontal circuit dysfunction by antidepressant-induced spine formation Science Magazine
A better understanding of the mechanisms underlying the action of antidepressants is urgently needed. Moda-Sava et al. explored a possible mode of action for ...
Racial profiling harms science Science Magazine
On behalf of the Society of Chinese Bioscientists in America (SCBA), the Chinese American Hematologist and Oncologist Network (CAHON), and the Chinese ...
High-fructose corn syrup enhances intestinal tumor growth in mice Science Magazine
Obesity increases an individual's risk of developing many types of cancer, including colorectal cancer. One of the factors driving the rise in obesity rates is ...
The As Have it
ALTERNATE AND PARALLEL UNIVERSES: - The modern science of physics has opened many pathways or doorways to the infinite possibilities of 'creation'. Evolution is not the only operational factor in our life and its purpose.
How Can DNA Testing Help an Immigration Case?
DNA testing is routinely used in immigration cases to prove whether a child under 18 is a biological child of or, in some cases, is related to an individual with a leave to remain in the UK. Most DNA tests for immigration reasons are parentage testing (paternity or maternity) but in some cases a grand parentage or avuncular (whether a child is a nephew or a niece of the sponsor) test is employed to prove an alleged relationship.
Locusts To Help Make Energy From Bio Waste, part IV
We are in a Plague year 2004-2005 where the locusts are swarming. No one knows how long this will last, but this problem could rage on for several more years.
Tactile Squeegee for Plexiglas Windows
Cleaning Plexiglas windows is not easy, you have to be careful to apply the right amount of pressure. Too little pressure and you do not clean it very well.
Get Hot on Combustion
Energy in the form of heat is obtained when fuel is burnt in air. The release of this heat energy can be slow or can be very rapid.
Why Can't Our Brain Process What We See Faster?
Many who admire the excellent design of Mother Nature and the gift of vision and the enhancements thru evolution wonder; Why Can't Our Brain Process What We See Faster? A paper by G. Bugmann and J.
UAV Acoustic Apparatus for Insect Swarming Stimulus, part two
UAV Acoustic Apparatus for Insect Swarming Stimulus, part two; Using Locust swarms to attack our enemies using directional sound to guide them.These plagues and swarms seem to occur randomly, although we do know the migrations are due to over population in an area.
The Future Enhancements of Tele-Robotics
Today we have already available UAVs, which will soon have the capacity of operating together in swarms, controlled from another nearby aircraft. We have UAVs, which can be flown by a pilot sitting at a desk more than 1000 miles away.
Megaliths and Pole Flips
The changes in the earth magnetic field away from the 7.8 cycle rhythm that it has been for a long time is something that may be a result of the things man has done to the Earth.
Electrical Industrys Protection - Destruction for Good
Destruction! Blow Up! Eliminate! These are not pleasant words!Unfortunately, when it comes to safety we have no other choices. In the electrical industry, fuses are destroyed in order to protect lives or property.
Glyco Nutrients & Stem Cell Production
During the speach, Dr. Reg McDaniel talked about first seeing new stem cells in the peripheral blood of clients using glyconutrients many years ago and not recognizing these cells as stem cells.
Rover Stuck on Mars?
NASA scientists had to solve a relatively common problem hear on Earth with the Rover on Mars. What do you do when you are stuck in the sand? Anyone who has ever raced off road or owned a 4X4, dune buggy or ATV understands these issues.
BI-LOCATION (PADRE PIO & PYTHAGORAS): - I have some experience with an even more 'fantastic' occurrence that ties in with dematerialization. Some approaches to the Bermuda Triangle might even be part of a dimensional shift and the time/worm hole science, which String Theorists and chaos science are able to provide arcane formulations to prove.
Bees Wax; History and Origin
We have often been asked where wax comes from? Well there are many types of Waxes. Bees wax has been around for a while.
Earthquakes, Tsunamis, Mudslides: Extreme Events - What Do They Mean?
In lieu of recent, tumultuous occurrences, people are more compelled than ever to discover the mystery of these modern-day, earth-changing events.One day, Earth(1) is experiencing the fourth largest earthquake in a century - a 9.
Remote Control Bacteria; We Can Not Allow That.
Remote Control Bacteria. Why not, we have remote control everything.
Troubleshooting Pump Problems the Easy Way
In any problem analysis, we have to specify the problem, check whether there is any deviation from the normal condition, identify the possible causes, evaluate the possible causes and then confirm the true cause.Pumps or other machinery will give tell tale signs when they are not working properly.
Life Under Mars Ice Shelf?
When looking for life on Mars we should be thinking of how life forms on Earth. Not because it will be similar, although it possibly could be, but because we know the things, which inhibit life and the things which help it flourish.
Ocean Polymer Goo to Stop Enemy Ships, a Concept
Naval blockade using polymer goo to stop fleeing ships might be possible. In this concept we will use the goo to stick to the bottom of the opposing navy's vessels.
What is Dowsing?
Dowsing is definitely an intuitive art and one of the oldest forms of divination in the world. Perhaps the oldest and most familiar image we have a dowser is what is called a field or map dowser.
|home | site map | Xray Photography|