Science Information

Paternity Testing Regulation: Help or Hindrance?


Introduction

The internet has opened up opportunities for many DNA laboratories to distribute free paternity test kits in hopes of a sale from returned samples. In Europe, France is the only country that regulates how paternity tests are conducted. Citizens of other European nations are free to satisfy their own curiosities and nagging doubts, while French citizens jump through hoops. Regulation and red tape protect some while hindering others.

Society Perspective

Pro: In 1941, the French government adopted a law called "Accouchement Sous X," or Childbirth Under X. This law allows a French woman to enter a hospital anonymously by signing her name as an X. Her identity and her child's identity are both kept anonymous. For a mother who has given birth anonymously, for whatever reason, a paternity test would surely break the anonymity. Mothers seeking refuge under the X law will undoubtedly seek the same protection under Article 16.

Alleged fathers will also benefit from this law because assessing paternity usually means child support payments. Years of due arrears may be charged to an alleged father if it is found that he is the biological father. Having a lawyer involved in the process for each case's beginning will give greater credibility to the test and its results. The transition from results to court decision is also smoothed and hastened by having a court-appointed lawyer.

Con: It's hard to say just how many people have forgone a paternity test because of the red tape involved. The majority of single mothers are in a less-than-favorable financial condition and probably can't afford to hire a lawyer.

Placing restriction on business operations shrinks the market, decreases competition, and drives up prices.

Business Perspective

Pro: DNA laboratories are able to sell a state utility service to virtually anyone through the postal service. The margin on DNA tests is high, and free home kits can be sent across international borders at a very low cost. French labs are much fewer than the number of labs in other countries, and the likelihood of business being conducted outside France is quite high. Large international laboratories could predatorily price their tests to the point where conducting a DNA test can no longer be done locally. DNA labs that are set up inside France will benefit from this legislation because French citizens are not permitted to conduct a test outside of the country. Although industry protection was not the reason for adding this article to the civil code, French labs capture the entire national market for paternity testing.

Con: Article 16 almost creates a public sector for paternity testing. The market size is reduced because fewer people will be willing conduct a test because of the increased complexity. In other countries, such as the UK and Germany, an individual can conduct a test almost whimsically. Having this new technology available to the general public at an affordable price has expanded the market size and allowed businesses to grow. In France, prices are relatively fixed. Consumers make choices based more on location than on price and quality.

The legislation also creates an entry barrier for other companies to enter the French market. In order for a laboratory in the UK to compete in France, it would need to expand operations and build inside the country. This infeasibility deters many businesses from expanding into France.

Conclusion

To some, red tape is an annoyance; to others, it is due process. Although Article 16-11 forces French citizens to undergo a more lengthy process when conducting a paternity test and hinders business competition, the article serves the best interest of the people. To make this legislation less burdensome, the court-appointed lawyer should be paid for by the state. This will allow more citizens to find the answers to their family-relation questions.

Tom LeBaron is a marketing representative of DNA Bioscience. Receive your own free home paternity testing kit, or learn more about DNA paternity testing in the UK.


MORE RESOURCES:

Science Center launches science festival
San Jose Mercury News,  USA - 8 hours ago
LOUIS—From hot-button issues in the newspaper to the fermented beer in the fridge, Americans are surrounded by science all the time. The St. Louis Science ...


Discover Magazine

Mars Science Lab Has Trouble Lifting Off; Might Make a “Nuclear ...
Discover Magazine, NY - 10 hours ago
Huge cost overruns and technical difficulties may cause the $2 billion dollar [sic] Mars Science Laboratory to be delayed or canceled outright, ...
Snow discovered on Mars McGill Tribune (subscription)
Science and Environment: Vision.org Examines International ... International Business Times
all 8 news articles


UT study could change the way science is taught to young children
Bizjournals.com, NC - 14 hours ago
It’sa question researchers at the University of Texas Center for Science and Math Education are pondering thanks to a $2 million grant from the National ...
ASU given grant to protect information WALB-TV
all 5 news articles


Scientific American

The Candidates on Climate Change Science
Washington Post, United States - 19 hours ago
Unlike the two most recent presidential elections, when there were stark differences between the candidates' views on climate science and policy, ...
Video: VP Debate - Climate Change: What is true and what is fals... CSPAN
Palin on global warming guardian.co.uk
all 30 news articles


Microsoft plans science of appliance for next SQL Server
Register, UK - 11 hours ago
Start your clocks and count the delays: Microsoft has named the first half of 2010 as the window for the next version of SQL Server - codenamed Kilimanjaro. ...


Solon student, Vibhuti Krishna, 13, is science contest finalist
The Plain Dealer - cleveland.com, OH - 54 minutes ago
Vibhuti Krishna, 13, of Solon, is among the 30 national finalists in the middle-school science competition sponsored by the Society for Science & the Public ...


BusinessWorld Online

Expert panel propose science, tech laws
Inquirer.net, Philippines - 5 hours ago
By Alexander Villafania PASAY City, Philippines -- A group of experts from the science, semiconductor, agriculture, education and energy sectors have sent ...
Science, technology commission extends term to work on projects GMA news.tv
S&T sectors seek legislative backing BusinessWorld Online
RP urged to consider nuclear power Manila Times
GMA news.tv - Inquirer.net
all 8 news articles


New America Foundation

The Science Coalition's '10 questions' for the presidential debate
EurekAlert (press release), DC - 18 hours ago
More than half of US economic growth in the past 60 years can be traced to science-driven technological innovation. The source of much of this innovation ...
Dear 44: 21st century innovation Politico
all 4 news articles


New Gibbons Make Home At Natural Science Center
WFMY News 2, NC - 10 hours ago
Greensboro, NC -- Earlier this year, the Natural Science Center lost two very beloved animals. Gibbons Beau and Jambi died under anesthesia. ...
One of two new gibbons recently added to the Greensboro Natural ... MyFox WGHP
all 2 news articles


Why Current Publication Practices May Distort Science
ScienceBlogs - 11 hours ago
Economic modelling of science may yield important insights. (Email is required for authentication purposes only. Comments are moderated for spam, ...

Science - Google News

home | site map | Xray Photography
© 2006