Science Information

How Can DNA Testing Help an Immigration Case?


DNA testing is routinely used in immigration cases to prove whether a child under 18 is a biological child of or, in some cases, is related to an individual with a leave to remain in the UK. Most DNA tests for immigration reasons are parentage testing (paternity or maternity) but in some cases a grand parentage or avuncular (whether a child is a nephew or a niece of the sponsor) test is employed to prove an alleged relationship.

When the child is outside the UK, a DNA test is normally arranged by an ECO. In such cases, DNA samples are taken from applicants at a post overseas and sent to a UK-based laboratory together with the samples of the sponsor, which in most cases is taken in the UK. If the child is already in the UK, DNA testing could be conducted in a Home Office-appointed laboratory or arranged privately or via solicitor. The DNA testing report provides an assessment as to the nature of relationship between the tested individuals and states the probability of this relationship.

According to the Home Office guidelines, in assessing DNA reports, the question to be addressed is whether the evidence establishes the relevant relationships on a balance of probability. If a DNA report concludes that the probability of a claimed relationship is at least three-times greater than any other relationship, it should normally be accepted as proof of that relationship without further enquiry. If the probability of the claimed relationship is only twice as likely (or less) than any other relationship, the case is usually reviewed as a whole. However, the Home Office admits that even a low balance of probability in favor of the claimed relationship is substantial evidence and should be accepted unless there is strong evidence to the contrary. If relationship was the sole ground on which the application was refused, and it was later established by means of DNA evidence, the Home Office usually concedes the case.

In cases where several children are to be tested, the fact that some children are related to the claimant does not constitute the evidence in favor of other children who were not tested. The application with regards to the latter will be refused on the ground that there is not enough evidence to support the alleged relationship unless DNA testing results prove otherwise.

When DNA testing proves the alleged relationship, the Home Office usually concedes the application however, in some cases, the Home Office has specific guidelines as to their treatment. This applies to cases when the child is related to only one of the parents, or is not related to them at all.

The immigration law treats a case where a child is related only to one of the parents differently. Treatment will depend on whether the child is related to the mother or to the father.

When the child is revealed to be the biological child of the father but not the mother, the Home Office usually seeks an explanation from the family on the following issues:

whether the child has been brought up and lives with the natural mother or the natural father

whether the child's mother is also seeking entry or whether she qualifies for admission

whether the father had exercised sole responsibility for the child's upbringing

whether the father had a previous undisclosed marriage or is in a polygamous marriage

Providing that the father is not in a polygamous marriage, has exercised the sole responsibility for the child's upbringing, and the child's mother is not seeking entry to the UK, the application is usually conceded by the Home Office.

When the child is related only to the mother, the situation is again different. This is a very delicate case and is usually handled with great sensitivity as the child may be illegitimate and the father may not be aware (even if he saw the DNA report). The impact of a disclosure of adultery could be disastrous for the woman. If the child has been brought up as child of the family he or she is usually admitted.

If DNA testing results indicate that the child is unrelated to the claimant, there may still be grounds for the Home Office to concede the application. If there is evidence that the child has been brought up as a member of the family he or she may be qualified for admission as de facto adopted child. In cases where the child is not a biological child of the parents but is related to them, the child may qualify as a dependant of a relative other than a parent.

DNA technology has significantly improved from the times when it was discovered, and now DNA testing has become a gold standard for cases where the relationship between people needs to be determined. Since 1985, thousands of children have been legally admitted to the UK and hundreds of families have been reunited. This can be largely attributed to Sir Alec Jeffreys' discovery of DNA fingerprinting 20 years ago.

The discovery of DNA fingerprinting 20 years ago has revolutionised the legal profession. Criminal and non-criminal justice systems were handed a very powerful tool to solve crime and resolve civil cases. Understanding how DNA testing can be applied in legal profession will bring benefits to both lawyers and their clients.

Avi was awarded the prestigious Shell Live Wire Entrepreneur of the Year award for his business. Working closely with the charities and various media outlets Avi strives to increase public awareness as to the benefits of DNA testing and the continuing impact that technological advances will have on all our lives.

Learn more about DNA profiling or how you can receive your own free home DNA paternity testing kit.


MORE RESOURCES:

District at or better than state science scores
Coon Rapids Herald, MN - 3 hours ago
The Minnesota Department of Education Tuesday released results from Minnesota’s inaugural online Science MCA-II testing. During the spring of 2008, ...
Area schools vary on science proficiency Litchfield Independent Review
Editorial: More work needed on science learning Minneapolis Star Tribune
Results mixed on MCA science test Farmington Independent
Crookston Daily Times - Winona Post
all 45 news articles


Western Governors University Expands Its Online Degrees in Science ...
MarketWatch - 10 hours ago
The need for highly-qualified science teachers is greater than ever. There are thousands of teacher job openings every year, and school districts struggle ...


Mayor says city still hopeful on Leonardo science center
Salt Lake Tribune, United States - 1 hour ago
... to spend the next several months hashing out a deal that may yet bring a science and culture center to the city's cement fortress at Library Square. ...
The Leonardo: It's time to decide Salt Lake Tribune
all 3 news articles


Seattle Post Intelligencer

Oil, Gas Seismic Work Not Affecting Gulf Sperm Whales, Study Shows
Science Daily (press release) - 5 hours ago
... say researchers from Texas A&M University who led the project and released their 323-page report today at the Houston Museum of Natural Science. ...
Study: Seismic has little effect on Gulf whales The Associated Press
Sperm whales live year-round in Gulf, new study finds Houston Chronicle
Study: Oil exploration doesn't harm whales United Press International
PhysOrg.com - KHOU
all 91 news articles


The Swedish-American Life Science Summit in Stockholm, August 20-22
MarketWatch - 9 hours ago
Against the uncertainties of the life science business and the unpredictable economic climate, the need for collaborative problem solving is greater than ...


AFP

UPI NewsTrack Health and Science News
United Press International - 4 hours ago
COLUMBUS, Ohio, Aug. 21 (UPI) -- US scientists monitoring Greenland's glaciers say they expect two of the largest glaciers to disintegrate within the next ...
At top of Greenland, new worrisome cracks in ice The Associated Press
Don’t read this if you want The Times
Continued breakup of Greenland's largest glaciers Hindu
io9 - The Tech Herald
all 133 news articles


New York Times

Search This Blog using Google
ScienceBlogs - 14 hours ago
Not many scientists were convinced the FBI had a solid science case against accused anthrax attacker Dr. Bruce Ivins. So the FBI held a telephone conference ...
Did FBI Scientists Identify a Single, Unique Flask? Lew Rockwell
Anthrax suspect's lawyer speaks up for FBI CNN
Local scientist helped solve anthrax puzzle WTOP
Science News - Salon
all 553 news articles


Dallas Morning News

Middle school teachers learn Infinity Project's science, math secrets
Dallas Morning News, TX - 18 hours ago
"In designing these modules, we said we have to include the science and the math but make it hands-on as well," said Rosemary Aguilar, ...


Texas Instruments Foundation inducts 10 teachers into its STEM Academy
MarketWatch - 5 hours ago
"The future competitiveness of our region's workforce depends on the development of critical science, technology, engineering and math skills," said TI ...


FBI Unveils Science Of Anthrax Investigation
Science Daily (press release) - 5 hours ago
Most people did not know that the work in Ray Goehner’s materials characterization department at Sandia National Laboratories was contributing important ...

Science - Google News

home | site map | Xray Photography
© 2006